Housing & planning · Woollahra Municipal Council
Rose Bay basement approval draws 12-1 objection from Woollahra Council
Council resolved to write to the NSW planning minister objecting to approval of the eight-storey, 49-apartment project at 23-31 Dover Road, citing predicted groundwater drawdown of up to 1.33 metres and a lack of cumulative modelling.

Reporting from draft minutes. Recorded wording may change when confirmed. How this article was prepared
Woollahra Council voted 12-1 to object to the State approval of an eight-storey, 49-apartment development at 23-31 Dover Road, Rose Bay, after recording concerns about groundwater, excavation and possible impacts on nearby properties, according to its unconfirmed minutes of 28 September 2026. Councillor James Ardouin was the sole vote against the objection.
The resolution records that the Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure approved the project, identified as SSD-86017721, on 14 September 2026. The development includes nine affordable housing apartments, two basement levels and 69 car spaces.
Council’s resolution says applicant modelling for the approximately nine-metre-deep basement predicted groundwater drawdown of up to 1.33 metres at 0.5 metres from the excavation face. It also records that the department-appointed reviewer did not provide basin-scale or cumulative groundwater modelling for the Rose Bay settlement area.
The resolution says the project’s consent contains no binding numeric limit on construction-stage groundwater drawdown. Instead, it requires the applicant to model the zone of influence through a dewatering management plan after consent was issued. Council says the absence of a drawdown cap is inconsistent with its development-control requirements for the Zone B settlement area.
Council also recorded that the reviewer rated the applicant’s documentation insufficient against six of 13 assessment criteria, including protection of neighbouring structures from excavation-related ground movement. It said evidence from residents’ independent experts, Council’s geotechnical representative and a state environment department recommendation about cumulative modelling was not reflected, or was not fully reflected, in the published assessment record. Those claims come from Council’s resolution and have not been independently tested for this report.
The resolution requests that the General Manager write to the Minister for Planning and Public Spaces, objecting to the approval and asking why the groundwater limit and specified technical evidence were not addressed. Council also wants no further LMR or affordable-housing-bonus State Significant Development applications involving basement excavation approved in the Rose Bay settlement area until a precinct-wide cumulative hydrogeological and geotechnical assessment is completed.
Council requested that the General Manager seek legal advice on options including possible Class 4 proceedings in the Land and Environment Court. The minutes do not record that Council has begun a court challenge to the Dover Road approval.
What deserves a closer look
The source records an adopted Council objection and requests for ministerial and legal responses, not a reversal of the State approval or completion of those requested actions.
The supplied minutes do not record whether the requested precinct-wide cumulative hydrogeological and geotechnical assessment will be commissioned.
The Item 15.4 division contains 12 names for the motion and one against, matching the recorded 12-1 result.
Questions for follow-up reporting
Will the Minister for Planning and Public Spaces or DPHI respond to Council's objection or alter the approval?
Will Council's requested legal advice recommend proceedings in the Land and Environment Court?
Who, if anyone, will commission the precinct-wide cumulative hydrogeological and geotechnical assessment requested by Council?
What happens next
Council requested that the General Manager write to the Minister for Planning and Public Spaces objecting to the approval.
Council requested that the correspondence ask why a binding numeric groundwater drawdown limit was not included and why specified technical evidence and recommendations were not addressed in the assessment record.
Council requested that the General Manager seek legal advice on its options, including possible Class 4 judicial review proceedings.
Council requested that a copy of the resolution and correspondence be sent to the Members for Vaucluse and Wentworth.
Check the record
These passages were matched to the source text. Read them in context in the original minutes.
The record is explicitly labelled unconfirmed minutes of Woollahra Municipal Council's Ordinary Council Meeting held on 28 September 2026.
Ordinary Council Monday, 28 September 2026 6:30 PM Minutes UNCONFIRMED Woollahra Municipal Council Ordinary Council 28 September 2026 Page | 2 Ordinary Council Meeting Minutes of the Meeting of Ordinary Council held at the Council Chambers, 536 New South Head Road, Double Bay, on 28 September 2026 at 6:30 PM.
Document title and meeting details
Open original minutes ↗James Ardouin is listed among the councillors present.
Present:Her Worship the Mayor, Councillor Sarah Dixson, ex-officio Councillors:Alexander Andruska James Ardouin Mary-Lou Jarvis Jeanette Mitchell Julian Parmegiani Harriet Price Lucinda Regan Matthew Robertson Mark Silcocks Torsten Merrill Witt Hugh Woodgate Toni Zeltzer Staff:Craig Swift-McNair - General Manager Jennifer Chenhall - Manager, Governance & Risk James Dolton - Chief Financial Officer Marcia Garrido - Governance & Meetings Officer Rhys Johnson - Team Leader Governance & Meeting Officer Melissa Lee - A/Coordinator, Governance & Risk Sue Meekin - Director, Corporate Performance Micaela Hopkins - A/Director, Infrastructure & Sustainability
Attendance list
Open original minutes ↗Council's resolution records that DPHI approved SSD-86017721 at 23-31 Dover Road, Rose Bay, on 14 September 2026: an eight-storey, 49-apartment development including nine affordable housing apartments, two basement parking levels and 69 car spaces.
(Councillor Witt/Councillor Parmegiani) 630/2026 Resolved: THAT Council: A. Notes that the Department of Planning Housing and Infrastructure (DPHI) approved SSD- 86017721 – an 8-storey residential flat building comprising 49 apartments, including 9 affordable housing apartments, with two levels of basement parking for 69 car spaces – at 23-31 Dover Road, Rose Bay on 14 September 2026, notwithstanding Council's formal objection recorded in DPHI's own Assessment Report (Section 4.4), which found among Council's outstanding concerns that: i.the proposal fails to minimise excavation and manage impacts, including the potential impact of construction
Item 15.4, Resolution 630/2026, Part A
Open original minutes ↗The quoted text notes that DPHI commissioned PSM to independently review the hydrogeological and geotechnical impacts of the proposed two-level, approximately nine-metre-deep basement excavation.
B. Notes that DPHI commissioned the geotechnical and engineering firm PSM to independently review the hydrogeological and geotechnical impacts of the proposed two- level, approximately 9 m deep basement excavation, and that in doing so PSM: i.developed its own composite Assessment Criteria informed by, but not bound by the July 2024 GHD Rose Bay Hydrogeological and Geotechnical Impacts Report (0.3 m for Settlement Zones A and B, 2.9 m for Zone C), and characterised Council's 0.3 m at the boundary dewatering control as a "conservative general screening tool" which could be exceeded subject to unspecified site-specific analysis;
Item 15.4, Resolution 630/2026, Part B
Open original minutes ↗The quoted text reports that the applicant's modelling predicts groundwater drawdown of up to 1.33 metres at 0.5 metres from the excavation face, and identifies a 0.3-metre limit applicable to the western, Zone B portion of the site.
UNCONFIRMED Woollahra Municipal Council Ordinary Council 28 September 2026 Page | 27 ii.noted that the Applicant's own modelling predicts groundwater drawdown of up to 1.33 m at 0.5 m from the excavation face — more than four times the 0.3 m limit applicable to the western, Zone B portion of the site — yet did not treat this as inconsistent with its overall conclusion that the development can be designed to comply;
Item 15.4, Resolution 630/2026, Part B(ii)
Open original minutes ↗The quoted text states that the PSM Review provides no basin-scale or cumulative groundwater modelling for the Rose Bay settlement area.
C. Notes that the PSM Review: i.provides no basin-scale or cumulative groundwater modelling for the Rose Bay settlement area, relying instead on GHD's general observation that the risk of impeding regional groundwater flow is "much lower" in Rose Bay than in Double Bay;
Item 15.4, Resolution 630/2026, Part C(i)
Open original minutes ↗The quoted text states that the consent contains no binding numeric limit on construction-stage groundwater drawdown, requires modelling rather than capping the zone of influence in a dewatering management plan submitted after consent, and says the lack of a specified dewatering control is inconsistent with Council's DCP for the Zone B settlement area.
H. Notes that the conditions of consent ultimately imposed do not include any binding numeric limit on construction-stage groundwater drawdown — Council's DCP drawdown controls appear nowhere in the operative conditions — and instead require the Applicant only to model, rather than cap, the zone of influence as part of a Dewatering Management Plan to be submitted after the consent has already issued (Condition A6(e); and that the lack of a specified dewatering control is not consistent with Council's DCP for the Zone B settlement area. I. Notes the extensive and growing record of excavation-related property damage in the immediate Rose Bay settlement area, including: multiple Building Commission NSW Stop Work Orders at 6-8 Richmond Road;
Item 15.4, Resolution 630/2026, Part H
Open original minutes ↗The quoted text states that PSM rated the applicant's documentation insufficient against six of 13 assessment criteria, including protection of neighbouring structures from excavation-induced ground movement, and that the DPHI Assessment Report did not disclose those itemised insufficiencies.
D. Notes that PSM's own Table 3 assessment rates the Applicant's documentation as INSUFFICIENT against 6 of 13 individual Assessment Criteria — including site characterisation, protection of neighbouring structures from excavation-induced ground movement, setbacks, the implementation plan and the dilapidation survey — yet the DPHI Assessment Report characterises PSM's findings in favourable terms, stating that PSM "considers that the Applicant has undertaken sufficient investigation... and provided an adequate level of investigation, analysis, design and reporting" (Assessment Report, Section 5.3.3), without disclosing the itemised insufficiencies recorded in PSM's own report.
Item 15.4, Resolution 630/2026, Part D
Open original minutes ↗Source record
Reporting from Woollahra Municipal Council’s public, explicitly unconfirmed minutes for the Ordinary Council Meeting held on 28 September 2026.
Key facts from the minutes
- DPHI approved the eight-storey, 49-apartment development at 23-31 Dover Road on 14 September 2026, according to the Council resolution.
- The project includes nine affordable housing apartments, two basement levels and 69 car spaces.
- Council’s resolution records applicant modelling predicting up to 1.33 metres of groundwater drawdown at 0.5 metres from the excavation face.
- The resolution says the consent contains no binding numeric limit on construction-stage groundwater drawdown.
- The unconfirmed minutes record that the objection passed 12-1, with Councillor James Ardouin against.
- Council resolved to request ministerial action, further cumulative assessment and legal advice, rather than deciding to stop the approved project itself.
Why it matters
- The approved project sits within a Rose Bay area where Council says multiple basement excavations could affect groundwater flows, flooding and nearby structures. Council’s resolution requests further assessment, ministerial action and legal advice; it does not reverse the State approval.