Housing & planning · Randwick City Council
Hospital operator challenges proposed heritage listing at 5 Dutruc Street
Randwick’s planning panel backed a proposal to list the health-service premises, saying heritage protection would not necessarily prevent continued operations. The panel’s advice is not a final listing decision.

Reporting from public council minutes. How this article was prepared
A proposed heritage listing for 5 Dutruc Street, Randwick, drew opposition from Eastern Suburbs Private Hospital at a meeting of the Randwick Local Planning Panel on 12 November 2026. The panel nevertheless unanimously advised Council that it supported preparing a planning proposal under item GR8/26, including the site’s listing, and submitting the draft to the Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure for Gateway Determination.
David Wenkart, identified in the public minutes as the chief executive officer of Macquarie Hospital Group and representing Eastern Suburbs Private Hospital, acknowledged the site’s contribution to the heritage conservation area but did not support listing it separately. His concern was that listing could unintentionally restrict the delivery of health services from the premises.
The panel’s recorded response was limited. It said heritage listing was not necessarily incompatible with ongoing service delivery from 5 Dutruc Street. The minutes do not say what future works or operational changes may be proposed at the site, or how they would be assessed if the listing proceeds.
The proposal would also list 199 Coogee Bay Road, Coogee, 11A Dudley Street, Randwick, and 128 Mount Street, Coogee. It would remove 37 Robey Street, Maroubra, from Schedule 5 of the Randwick Local Environmental Plan 2012.
The panel said 11A Dudley Street’s external and internal fabric was in exceptional original condition. At 128 Mount Street, it said immediate remedial work was needed to maintain the external building fabric and supported the proposed listing. The proposal also includes housekeeping amendments affecting 1A Waltham Street, Avoca Street and existing heritage item sites in Coogee.
The panel’s unanimous support is for preparing and progressing the planning proposal, not for final changes to the local environmental plan. The minutes do not give a timetable for Gateway Determination or any later heritage listing.
What deserves a closer look
The minutes record the panel's view that heritage listing and continued health-service delivery are not necessarily incompatible, but they do not resolve how particular future works or operational changes would be assessed.
The approved panel resolution is advisory: it supports preparing a planning proposal and submitting the draft for Gateway Determination. The minutes do not record Council approval, submission or completed amendments to the Randwick Local Environmental Plan.
Questions for follow-up reporting
If Council progresses the proposal, what timetable would apply to Gateway Determination?
What future works or operational changes at 5 Dutruc Street would be affected if the proposed listing proceeds?
What remedial work is required at 128 Mount Street, and would it require approvals if the proposed listing proceeds?
What happens next
If Council progresses the proposal, the panel supports preparing it and submitting the draft to the Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure for Gateway Determination. The minutes do not record Council approval, submission or a timetable.
Check the record
These passages were matched to the source text. Read them in context in the original minutes.
Under item GR8/26, the panel resolved to advise Council that it supported preparing a planning proposal to amend Schedule 5, Part 1 of the Randwick LEP 2012 and submitting the draft to the Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure for Gateway Determination.
The Panel then moved to the Coogee Room to deliberate and vote on each matter. The resolutions, reasons and voting outcomes for each item on the agenda are detailed below: MINUTES OF RANDWICK LOCAL PLANNING PANEL MEETING 12 NOVEMBER 2026 This is page 2 of the Minutes of the Randwick Local Planning Panel (Public) meeting held on 12 November 2026 General Reports GR8/26 General Report - Planning Proposal - Heritage items and housekeeping amendments to Schedule 5, Part 1 of the Randwick Local Environmental Plan 2012 (F2016/00475) RESOLUTION: 1. That the Randwick Local Planning Panel advises Council that it supports the preparation of a planning proposal for changes to Schedule 5, Part 1 - Heritage Items of the Randwick LEP 2012 as set out below and to submit the draft Planning Proposal to the Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure for Gateway Determination pursuant to the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 : a.
GR8/26 heading and resolution
Open original minutes ↗The proposed changes would list four properties, including 5 Dutruc Street, Randwick, and remove 37 Robey Street, Maroubra, as a heritage item.
List the following properties as heritage items: o 199 Coogee Bay Road, Coogee; o 5 Dutruc Street, Randwick; o 11A Dudley Street, Randwick; and o 128 Mount Street, Coogee. b. Remove the following property as a heritage item: o 37 Robey Street, Maroubra (I228) c.
GR8/26 resolution, proposed listings and removal
Open original minutes ↗The minutes list David Wenkart as representing Eastern Suburbs Private Hospital in a deputation against the proposal concerning 5 Dutruc Street, Randwick.
Address of RLPP by Councillors and members of the public Deputations were received in respect of the following matters: GR8/26 PLANNING PROPOSAL - HERITAGE ITEMS AND HOUSEKEEPING AMENDMENTS TO SCHEDULE 5, PART 1 OF THE RANDWICK LOCAL ENVIRONMENTAL PLAN 2012 Against Kieran Turner (re: 199 Coogee Bay Rd, Coogee) - 1st speaker Against David Wenkart, representing Eastern Suburbs Private Hospital (re: 5 Dutruc St, Randwick) - 2nd speaker For Miroslav Markovic (re: 37 Robey St, Maroubra) – 3rd speaker After the above speakers had addressed the panel, the public meeting was closed at 1:18pm.
Public deputations on GR8/26
Open original minutes ↗David Wenkart was identified as Macquarie Hospital Group's chief executive officer, acknowledged the proposed item's contribution to the heritage conservation area and did not support separate listing of 5 Dutruc Street.
MINUTES OF RANDWICK LOCAL PLANNING PANEL MEETING 12 NOVEMBER 2026 This is page 3 of the Minutes of the Randwick Local Planning Panel (Public) meeting held on 12 November 2026 5 Dutruc Street, Randwick The Panel heard from David Wenkart (the Chief Executive Officer of Macquarie Hospital Group) who acknowledged the contribution of the proposed item to the heritage conservation area but did not support separate listing.
5 Dutruc Street, Randwick
Open original minutes ↗The concern raised was about unintended restrictions on health-service delivery, and the panel said listing was not necessarily incompatible with ongoing service delivery.
His concern was unintentional restrictions on the delivery of health services from premises. The Panel does not consider the heritage listing to necessarily be incompatible with the ongoing service delivery from the premises.
5 Dutruc Street, Randwick
Open original minutes ↗The panel observed that 11A Dudley Street's external fabric was in exceptional original condition and said the heritage assessment demonstrated the same condition for its interior.
11A Dudley Street, Randwick The Panel strongly agrees with the recommendation. The Panel observed that the external fabric of the building is in exceptional original condition. The heritage assessment demonstrates that the interior of the building is also in exceptional original condition.
11A Dudley Street, Randwick
Open original minutes ↗The panel noted immediate remedial work was needed to maintain the external building fabric at 128 Mount Street and supported its proposed heritage listing.
128 Mount Street, Coogee The Panel observed at the site that the building is in need of immediate remedial work to ensure the integrity of the external building fabric is maintained. The Panel accepts that the proposed item has sufficient heritage significance to warrant listing. The Panel supports the recommendation. 37 Robey Street, Maroubra The Panel observed that there is no evident heritage significance remaining and supports the removal of it from Schedule 5 of the Randwick LEP.
128 Mount Street, Coogee
Open original minutes ↗The amendments include a spelling correction at 1A Waltham Street, an extension of the listing and mapping at 231 Avoca Street to include 229 Avoca Street, and additional addresses for existing heritage item sites at 1 Berwick Street and 5 Kurrawa Avenue, Coogee.
Correct the spelling of the item name of 1A Waltham Street, Coogee (I101) to "Maidstone" d. Extend the heritage listing and mapping from 231 Avoca Street, Randwick, to include 229 Avoca Street, Randwick e. Add the legal address, 109a Mount Street, Coogee to the heritage item site at 1 Berwick Street, Coogee f. Add the address, 146-152 Beach Street, Coogee, to the heritage item site at 5 Kurrawa Avenue, Coogee and add the word "complex" in its item name description.
GR8/26 resolution, additional amendments
Open original minutes ↗Source record
Reporting from the public minutes of the Randwick Local Planning Panel (Public) meeting held by Randwick City Council on 12 November 2026. Confirmation status is not established by the supplied record.
Key facts from the minutes
- The Randwick Local Planning Panel unanimously advised Council on 12 November 2026 that it supported preparation of a planning proposal under item GR8/26.
- The proposal would list four properties, including 5 Dutruc Street, and remove 37 Robey Street from Schedule 5 of the Randwick LEP 2012.
- The panel’s resolution supports submitting the draft proposal to the Department of Planning, Housing and Infrastructure for Gateway Determination; it does not record that submission occurred.
- The minutes record opposition to separate listing of 5 Dutruc Street from a representative of Eastern Suburbs Private Hospital over possible effects on health-service delivery.
- The panel said 128 Mount Street needed immediate remedial work and supported its proposed listing.
Why it matters
- 5 Dutruc Street is used for health services, and the hospital representative raised concerns that separate heritage listing could unintentionally restrict their delivery. The panel supported progressing the proposal but did not establish that listing would permit or prevent any particular operation or building work.